Archive for Player Comparison

Fantasy Throwdown: Nolan Arenado vs. Manny Machado: Which Young 3B Is The Better Bet?

by Eric Stashin (aka The Rotoprofessor)

Both Nolan Arenado and Manny Machado are squarely on fantasy radars, whether it be redraft leagues or dynasty formats. Both have the potential to be top options for many years to come, but who is actually the better target? Let’s try to figure it out:

2014 Statistics

Nolan Arenado432.2871861582
Manny Machado327.2781232382

Manny Machado
Knee injuries have cut his last two seasons short, otherwise you have to wonder if this would even be a debate. There was nothing unrealistic in Machado’s average last season (20.5% line drive rate, .317 BABIP, 19.2% strikeout rate) and he showed some growth in the power department.

Is a 15.0% HR/FB believable? His average distance on non-groundballs of 267.986 was up from 262.402 in 2013 and he’s still just 22-years old. Would it really be a surprise that he’s showing a bit more power? Read more

2015 Fantasy Throwdown: Hunter Pence vs. Alex Gordon

by Eric Stashin (aka The Rotoprofessor)

They squared off in the 2014 World Series, but who is actually the better option heading into 2015 fantasy drafts?  While a lot could change between now and draft day, it’s definitely an interesting comparison to make.

First let’s compare the numbers from last season, which are extremely similar:

Hunter Pence
Alex Gordon
Home Runs2019
Stolen Bases1312

Outside of the runs scored, there clearly wasn’t much difference. So, with that in mind, let’s take a look at the upside in each category to help reach our decision.

Pence has hit at least 20 HR in seven consecutive seasons, including four of at least 25. While his power was down last season, he did hit 27 in his first year in San Francisco though he has shown a dramatic home/road split in the two years since the trade: Read more

Bounce Back or Bust: Could Jason Castro Be A Viable Option In 2015?

by Eric Stashin (aka The Rotoprofessor)

After breaking out in 2013, with a line of .276 with 18 HR and 56 RBI over 491 PA, a lot was expected of Jason Castro in 2014. Always a player who hit the ball hard (25.2% line drive rate), there was a lot to like. Unfortunately we witnessed a regression across the board:

465 At Bats
.222 Batting Average (103 Hits)
14 Home Runs
56 RBI
43 Runs
1 Stolen Bases
.286 On Base Percentage
.366 Slugging Percentage
.294 Batting Average on Balls in Play

The first thing to note is his big drop in average. His strikeout number wasn’t great in 2013 (26.5%), but it jumped to 29.5% last season. In fact he didn’t have a month below 27% all season, and hasn’t since June 2013. In other words, expecting a major change is a mistake. Read more

Rest of Season: Dustin Pedroia vs. Anthony Rendon

by Eric Stashin (aka The Rotoprofessor)

Prior to the season this would’ve been a ridiculous debate, as Pedroia was widely viewed as a Top 5 option at his position. However, at this stage you could likely make an argument either way (all stats are through Saturday):

  • Pedroia – .266, 4 HR, 27 RBI, 41 R, 2 SB
  • Rendon – .274, 11 HR, 42 RBI, 45 R, 5 SB

There’s little question that Rendon has been the better player, thus far, but can he maintain it? Is he the better option over the rest of the season?  Let’s take a look:


The question is, what’s exactly happened? A .300 career hitter, his drop in average has been due to poor luck more than anything. While his strikeouts are up, would a 12.0% mark really concern anyone? The problem is in his BABIP, which currently sits at .293. Considering he actually owns a career best 24.2% line drive rate, expecting an improvement should be easy. Making it even easier is the fact that he’s had a mark of 23.4% or better in each month.

Read more

Fantasy Throwdown: Danny Salazar vs. Noah Syndergaard: Which Young Starter Is A Better Dynasty Target?

The latest Fantasy Throwdown takes a little bit of a different twist, as we go dynasty!  Which pitcher would be a better investment for the long-term, the Indians’ Danny Salazar or the Mets’ Noah Syndergaard?  Let’s take a look at the arguments:


Will Overton – In Favor Of Danny Salazar
In a dynasty league the prospect we haven’t seen is almost always more enticing than the prospect we have. It’s that element of the unknown that appeals to us, because we can imagine someone to be as good as we want if we’ve never seen him in the big leagues. I like Noah Syndergaard, don’t get me wrong, but I’m going to side with the young guy who has been to the majors and excelled.

Danny Salazar went from Double-A to the Major Leagues last season and showed himself very capable of being a top of the rotation pitcher. He struck out well over 11 batters per nine last year and coupled it with an excellent walk rate of less than three per nine.

Read more

Fantasy Throwdown: Elvis Andrus vs. Everth Cabrera: Which Stolen Base Threat Should You Target?

When you are looking for a shortstop, you could easily find yourself trying to decide between two “pure” speed options in Elvis Andrus and Everth Cabrera.  Who is actually the better draft day investment?  Let’s see what the Rotoprofessor writers think:

Will Overton – The Case For Elvis Andrus
I think there is a common misconception out there that Everth Cabrera is a younger, still budding player, unlike Elvis Andrus. The fact is that they both came in the league as rookies in 2009 and Cabrera is actually two years older. I think people are souring a bit on Andrus because he hasn’t progressed as far as some expected, but he’s still clearly a better player than Cabrera for fantasy purposes.

Andrus has never hit below .265 in his five seasons in the Majors. Cabrera is a lifetime .252 hitter. He clearly made progress last year reaching .283, but one year doesn’t trump five years of consistency.

Read more