Comments on: 2010 Dynasty Rankings: Top 25 Outfielders: A First Look

By: Rotoprofessor

Rotoprofessor — Tue, 23 Feb 2010 00:51:58 +0000

cdog, this was an extremely preliminary list posted in November. I’m currently updating all of the Dynasty League rankings, so keep checking back. While it’s not finalized, both should be represented this next time around.

By: cdog

cdog — Tue, 23 Feb 2010 00:36:41 +0000

The absence of mccutchen and adam jones on tthis list is disturbing me. I take them easily over most guys on this list in a dynasty draft. Maybe I’m crazy.

By: Dave

Dave — Sat, 13 Feb 2010 15:44:25 +0000

Where’s Andrew McCutchen? If this is a dynasty list, I’d have him infront of alot of these guys, (Werth, Cruz, Quentin, Manny, Carlos Lee, and Beltran).

By: rolf

rolf — Tue, 22 Dec 2009 00:46:52 +0000

this time next year, justin upton is #1

By: TY

TY — Wed, 18 Nov 2009 17:14:36 +0000

Yes… Holliday should be before Lind b/c i think Lind is SOLID but he doesn’t run. Holliday will steal you 10-20 bags. I think braun, kemp, J-upton and sizemore are your 4 best OF’ers. Crawford is going to burn people who pay for him next year…. AGAIN. He was always overrated, the one year he isn’t overrated and goes where he probably should have for the 3 previous years he breaks out, now overrated again.

I wouldn’t trust Beltran for a second to be healthy, and in that park…. NO THANKS, at #7, no way…. Holliday in St. Louis or BOSTON? YES PLEASE.

You have to take Werth and Cruz ahead of markakis… YOU HAVE TO.

Markakis use to be my boy, but i’m convinced he’s maybe one of the most overrated overdrafted of the OF’ers….

18HRS 6SB’s and a .293 average? WEAK

He’s truly a 20HR/20SB MAX .300 hitter…. not a bad line, but not great and Definitely not worth a 3rd to 4th round pick like he was going last year, and yes i know 3 years ago he went 23HR/18SB and hit .300 but that was a different team and we’ve seen him dip for two years now…. CHOO went 10 rounds later and put up better stats. Everyone listed below Markakis basically went after him in drafts and outperformed him, most by ALOT.

OVERRATED.

BJ UPTON needs to be higher on potential alone. He does have a brother in the league, they come from the same gene pool. Say he’s even just a 10HR/45SB guy? Thats better than some of those other OF’ers… with the potential he could go 20-30HR’s and 45SB’s if it all clicks…. its all about the UPSIDE. You can’t hate that RAYS offense either? WOW, youth, speed, power, POTENTIAL…..

thats all for now…. HA

By: Jimmy

Jimmy — Mon, 16 Nov 2009 16:02:54 +0000

I think Lind is too high, he needs to prove himself more before I consider him a top-10 option in keeper leagues. I’m not saying he isn’t worthy of being high in the rankings, I just think outside of the top-10 (11 or 12) is where he belongs for right now.