2012 Projection: Why Brett Lawrie Should Already Be Considered A Top Option At 3B

Brett Lawrie was supposed to be the next great third base option for fantasy owners to lean on.  We all anxiously anticipated his debut with the Toronto Blue Jays, only to see a broken hand delay his arrival for a few additional weeks (before a knee injury ended things prematurely).  However, when he was on the diamond he showed that the talent lived up to the hype:

150 At Bats
.293 Batting Average (44 Hits)
9 Home Runs
25 RBI
26 Runs
7 Stolen Bases
.373 On Base Percentage
.580 Slugging Percentage
.318 Batting Average on Balls in Play

If he’s that good or not is an interesting question, but it has become abundantly clear that Lawrie is a player that all fantasy owners need to take note of.  Acquired in the deal that sent Shaun Marcum to Milwaukee, Lawrie clearly is a player on the rise.

Lawrie hit primarily seventh upon his debut (80 AB), though in a deep lineup that’s not a huge detriment to his value.  We all know that Adam Lind and Jose Bautista are going to hit in the middle of the lineup.  Colby Rasmus will probably be in the second spot (at least initially), hitting behind Eric Thames.  That leaves Edwin Encarnacion and Brett Lawrie to fill in the fifth and sixth holes (with J.P. Arencibia and Yunel Escobar coming in behind them).  In other words, the lineup is going to provide more than enough protection and opportunity for Lawrie to perform.

Opportunity is obviously only half the battle.  Is his skill level there to be an elite option?

One thing that he gives owners a huge advantage is in the speed game.  A former second baseman, Lawrie has stolen 30 bases in a season before (at Double-A in 2010) and showed the potential to be a 20+ stolen base guy upon his arrival to the Major Leagues.  Now a third baseman, how man other players at the position give you that upside?

At one point you would’ve thought David Wright would do it, but with his back issues that no longer feels like a certainty.  Emilio Bonifacio obviously can (he could easily surpass 40 atop the Marlins lineup), but he offers nothing in the power or RBI departments.  Who else possibly could accomplish it?  Ryan Roberts?  In other words, his ability to steal bases immediately gives him an advantage over the rest of the field.

The fact that he also brings home run potential makes him that much more appealing.  He hadn’t shown that much power prior to 2011, but he hit 27 HR between Triple-A and the Majors.  Granted, 18 of them came in the Pacific Coast League so we want to take that with a little bit of a grain of salt.  His number in the Major Leagues also appears to be a little bit inflated, coming courtesy of a 17.0% HR/FB.

However, at Double-A in 2010 he had 59 extra base hits (35 doubles, 16 triples and 8 home runs).  He’s getting older and gaining strength, meaning the additional power is not completely unbelievable.  Given his history I wouldn’t call it a given that he reaches 20+ HR, but he has that type of upside and should at least come close.

As I stated before, he hits in a deep lineup so no matter what spot he settles into he should bring the potential to both score and drive in runs.  Anticipating him reaching at least 80 in both departments would be incredibly realistic.  In fact, it wouldn’t be a surprise to see him far exceed either number.

He also brings a solid average to the table.  A fall in power is going to hurt him a little bit but he doesn’t strikeout a lot (18.1% in ’11) and wasn’t excessively lucky last season.  All he needs to do is add a little bit of luck and he could easily replicate last season’s mark.  Even if he regresses a little bit, the average is going to be more than usable.

You put everything together and you get the following prediction for next season:

.282 (155-550), 19 HR, 85 RBI, 80 R, 23 SB, .324 BABIP, .342 OBP, .473 SLG

We all know that third base is among the weakest positions in all of fantasy sports.  Now, you get a young option with the potential to go 20/20/80/80, at the worst.  It wouldn’t be a surprise to see him surpass the projections and entrench himself as a Top 5 option by year’s end, either.  It’s a no-brainer to get your hands on him and consider him one of the better options in the league for 2012.

What are your thoughts of Lawrie?  What type of numbers are you expecting from him in 2012?  Is he a player you feel is a must own?

***** Don’t miss the opportunity to participate in Rotoprofessor’s Black Friday Sale!  Time is running out to pre-order our 2012 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide for just $5.  With constant updates until the start of the season, this is the gift that keeps on giving.  Click here for details and to order. *****

Make sure to check out our other 2012 projections:


  1. john says:

    Sshhhhhh,,,Take this article down before the salary game sites see it and raise BL up 🙂

  2. jmax says:

    When you post anything Blue Jays I’m sure I’ll comment.
    I have to agree with your backing of Brett the Hitman Lawrie (weak nickname I know). I haven’t seen many players like him period! Rookie or veteren. He plays with so much energy and enthusiasm. Add in the power and the speed and we have a superstar in the making. Please understand am I in no way bias to my countries team. Tune in to a Blue Jays game and any doubter will see for himself.
    Many of us Blue Jay fans aren’t sold on Eric Thames. If there is a stinker put up by Thames do you think we could see Brett hitting out of the 2 hole in 2012??

    • jmax says:

      I know Rasmus is tenatively slated for the 2 hole but I really dont see him as a 2 hitter. Especially if he doesn’t come out swinging. Rasmus can’t get by on potential alone in my books

    • Rotoprofessor says:

      I don’t disagree and it is possible that Lawrie moves into that spot at some point. However, I don’t think Thames will have any impact on where Lawrie hits. I don’t see Lawrie as a leadoff man, barring the team being absolutely desperate.

  3. Brian Blair says:

    I certainly like all the names mentioned in this article, with one exception…Rasmus!

  4. bigmover2003 says:

    Any thoughts on Anthony Gose? Do you think Toronto will give him a shot at any point this year? He is fast but that high strikout rate doesn’t look so good.

  5. bA says:

    No way he only hits 19 homers (unless he only gets 300 abs again) as when you project his #’s for last year he would have hit 18 homers in 300ab’s. Minimum

    I won’t be surprised to see Lawrie outproduce Longo.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *