2012 First Round Analysis: Does Robinson Cano Belong Among The Top 12?

Position scarcity or not, it is hard to argue with the ability of the New York Yankees’ Robinson Cano.  It’s not hard to make the claim that he is one of the best hitters in the game.  Considering the supporting cast around him and the ballpark he plays in, there is no question that he is going to be given the opportunity to produce some impressive numbers once again in 2012.  The question is if the upside makes him worth taking in the first round of this year’s fantasy drafts?  Let’s take a look:

2011 Numbers:
.302 (188-623), 28 HR, 118 RBI, 104 R, 8 SB

The Case For Him:
Obviously, doing the things he does as a second baseman gives him a significant advantage over the rest of the field.  Just look at his numbers compared to other second basemen:

  • Home Runs – He is one of only three second baseman with 22+ HR in ’11 (Dan Uggla hit 36 and Ian Kinsler hit 32). 
  • RBI – He was the only second baseman to have over 92 RBI (Dustin Pedroia & Ben Zobrist each had 91).  The only other second basemen to drive in over 100 runs in a season in the past five years were Dan Uggla (105 in ’10), Aaron Hill (108 in ’09) and Chase Utley (104 in ’08 and 103 in ’07)
  • Runs – He was one of three second basemen with at least 100 runs (and five with 94 or more)
  • Average – Among second basemen who qualified for the batting title, only three batted at least .300 (Dustin Pedroia & Brandon Phillips were the other two). 

The funny thing about Cano’s season is that there is actually room for improvement.  He saw his strikeout rate rise to a career high of 14.1% (the prior three seasons he was between 9.3% and 11.1%).  A reduction there, as well as an improvement in his BABIP (he was at .316 in ’11 compared to .324 and .326 the prior two seasons) will mean an improvement in his batting average.  It’s not that anyone is going to complain about a .302 average, but .320 is a realistic expectation.

He also hits in one of the strongest lineups in the game and should settle into either the third, fourth or fifth spot in the order.  That’s going to mean ample opportunities with runners on base (he hit .318 with RISP in ’11 and .322 in ’10), and he should also score more than enough runs once again.  In other words, it’s pretty easy to pencil him in for .310/25/100/100 once again, with the potential for even more than that.

Forget about second basemen, how many players in the game can you expect that from?

The Case Against Him:
There isn’t much not to like about Cano, but if you want to point towards one thing it is his lack of speed.  When you are selecting someone in the first round often times you want him to give you an advantage across the board.  Unfortunately, second base is a position where you can find stolen bases from, something Cano does not offer.

There were 11 second basemen who stole at least 15 bases in 2011, so by selecting Cano you do put yourself behind the eight ball slightly.  Is it enough to cause owners to avoid him, however?

Outside of the lack of speed, there is nothing not to like about Cano.  You can count the hitters on one hand who bring to the table what he does.  When you couple that with the lineup he hits in (which gives him plenty of opportunities) and the ballpark he calls home it really is hard to knock him.  The fact is, he wouldn’t need to be a second baseman to be under consideration for the first round, but since he is he looks that much more impressive.

He’s not going to go in the first few picks, but mid-to-late in the first round he is way too good of a selection to pass up.  Consider him a good pick at the tail end of the first round in all formats.

What are your thoughts of Cano?  Do you think he belongs in the first round?  Why or why not?

***** Pre-order the Rotoprofessor 2012 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide, complete with updates from January through the start of the season, for just $6!  To place your order click here. *****

Make sure to check out our other 2012 projections:


  1. TY says:

    Im not a fan of taking him in the top 12, but his numbers are consistent, and do I want a consistent pick in my #1 or some guy with “potential”? Well i want both, but we can’t have it all, i’d take cano’s numbers and the fact you can pencil him in for .300+ 20HR+ and 90+ rbi…. sb’s and more are gravy.

  2. beardawg says:

    I don’t totally disagree, but might have a slight preference for Pedroia. Less HR but probably more R, AVG, and definitely more SB

  3. mtnrider says:

    Completely depends on your format. I’d much rather have all the points that his power generates in my H2H league over some steals. In roto, that is a different story, though Cano is still a stud.

  4. Rotoprofessor says:

    mtnrider – I do agree that the format will play an issue, but regardless he’s got to at least be in the discussion. There is just too much talent and, as TY stated, you know exactly what you are going to get.

    beardawg – I agree Pedroia will have more SB than Cano, but R and AVG will at least be close if you don’t think Cano is going to be better (in the average department I think Cano has him).

  5. SimonJ - Trade Counsel says:

    Cano has to be in the mix for a top 10 draft pick. You are much more likely to lose your league with your first pick than win it. I’m looking for the highest floor rather than the highest ceiling with this pick. Sure you may lose out on SBs but those other stats and the security that comes with them are gold. I don’t see him as a top 5 guy, but definitely top 10.

  6. Daniel says:

    No, i dont think that it is a given that Cano is the best second baseman. Hrs-you said that kinsler has more. rbi-hes the only one out of pedroia-kinsler-cano that bats in a position to get lots of rbi. runs-Kinsler beat him by alot. average. right. lets look at the much more relevant stat of obp. pedroia wins, kinsler and cano are close. so, using your categories (which i don’t agree are good for assessing the best player) its kinsler-cano-pedroia for HR, cano-pedroia-kinsler for rbi, kinsler-cano-pedroia for runs, and pedroia-cano-kinsler for avg. its 9 points cano, 8points kinsler, 7 points pedroia. and this is using your stats, which includes the ridiculous stat of average and rbi which is obviously in favor of cano. then theres the speed…obviously based on those four stats you used if you added speed to the mix kinsler would win. I know, kinsler’s average and injury risk is a worry, but his BABIp was miserably and if he can get it up to his career norm he should hit .275-.290 and move his obp up to the high 3s.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *