First Round Analysis: Why Evan Longoria Should Be Considered

There was a time, however brief, that Evan Lognoria was viewed as the top third baseman in the game.  The presence of Jose Bautista has definitely changed that recently, though 2012 may be the final year that he has eligibility at the position (thanks to Brett Lawrie joining the Blue Jays).  Recent struggles also haven’t done fantasy owners any favors in valuing Longoria.  It’s not that he’s had bad seasons in general, but there have been different issues each of the past two seasons:

  • 2010 – His power fell off, hitting just 22 HR
  • 2011 – His average plummeted, hitting .244

Given those issues it is hard to imagine that he would still be under consideration for the first round, wouldn’t it?  However, I wouldn’t be so quick to write him off for the final few picks of the opening round.  Let’s take a look at why.

2011 Numbers:
.244 (118-483), 31 HR, 99 RBI, 78 R, 3 SB

The Case For Him:
While there have been issues the past few seasons they all can be written off.  The power drop off from 2010?  He still had a ton of extra base hits in 2009 (46 doubles and 5 triples) and he obviously came back strong in 2011.  Just look at his HR/FB numbers for his career and tell me which one doesn’t belong:

  • 2008 – 19.4%
  • 2009 – 17.6%
  • 2010 – 11.1%
  • 2011 – 17.6%

There is no reason to think that he is not going to be a 30+ HR hitter once again, especially considering he achieved that feat in just 483 AB (133 games) last season. 

As for last year’s average problems, while he may have been swinging for the fences a little bit more (44.7% fly ball rate compared to a 42.8% career mark) the culprit was clearly his BABIP.  After posting marks above .300 in his first three years in the majors he posted a pathetic .239 mark last season.  Does anyone really believe in that number?  It was actually tied for the third worst mark in the league and we have to assume that he’s going to rebound strong.

While the Rays lineup may not be what it once was, they are still going to produce plenty of runs.  Last season the Rays scored 707 runs, right in the middle of the league.  Longoria has proven to have 100/100 potential (he achieved it in 2009 and was at 104 RBI and 96 R in 2010).

Last season there was only one third baseman who had over 100 RBI and over 90 R (Jose Bautista).  There were four who had over 90 RBI and over 80 R (Bautista, Michael Young, Adrian Beltre and Aramis Ramirez).  In other words, assuming Longoria can get back to his proven levels he gives you a major advantage over the rest of the field.

The Case Against Him:
Obviously if you are selecting Longoria you are doing so, at least partially, due to position scarcity.  It’s not that the potential numbers are not impressive, but is he going to out perform someone like Prince Fielder (who likely isn’t even a consideration in the first round)?  What about someone like Andrew McCutchen, who also offers speed?

Sure, Longoria stole 15 bases in 2010 but that’s clearly not the norm.  He only had three stolen bases last season and only had 8 SB over his minor league career.  From a first round pick, don’t you want someone who is going to help you across the board?

There also is a little bit of risk involved, considering the issues he’s had the past two years.  As the old saying goes you can’t win your league in the first round but you definitely can lose it.  Why take a risk when you don’t necessarily have to?

While he has had his issues the past two seasons and doesn’t offer much speed, that isn’t enough to dissuade me.  He’s far from a lock to be selected in the first round, but depending on how things fall I would at least consider him at the very end of the round (he is a lock to go in the first few picks of the second round).  Figure picks 10-12 would make sense depending on the format and who is selected ahead of him.

There is just too much to like about Longoria at this point and the issues that he’s had are easily explained away.  As we head into 2012 I don’t see any reason not to expect him to hit .280+ with 30+ HR, 100+ RBI and 90+ R.  Considering those numbers come from one of the shallowest positions in the game, they are too appealing to ignore.

What are your thoughts of Longoria?  Is he a player you would consider picking in the first round?  Why or why not?

***** Order the Rotoprofessor 2012 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide, complete with updates from January through the start of the season, for just $6! As an added bonus, if you purchase by 3/15 you will be entered to win a Michael Pineda autographed baseball! To place your order click here. *****

Make sure to check out our other 2012 first round analysis:


  1. Chuck says:

    Good call, the more I think about it, the more I want to end up picking with the 10-12th pick in my Yahoo draft. When I see the rankings of players in the middle-end of the second round, I really don’t know what to think. I’d much rather end up with Cano + Longo and skip the issue altogether…

  2. jmax says:

    Does the addition of Carlos Pena add a little value to Longoria?

  3. Pochucker says:

    In my live draft last Sunday , I was shocked to have Longoria fall to me at pick #20 (12t-mx). After I already was shocked by Braun dropping to me @5 in first rd. You never know –first pitcher went in 3rd first closer in 7th.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *