Draft Day Decision: Five Shortstops To Avoid In 2012

There are a lot of reasons that people may suggest not drafting a player.  It could be based on injuries (both a high risk for one or the recovery of a previous one), potential loss of playing time, diminishing performance or various things in between.  Let’s take a look at five catchers I likely won’t be drafting in 2012:

1) Elvis Andrus – Texas Rangers
I am one of Andrus’ biggest supporters, but things have gotten a bit out of control.  According to Mock Draft Central his ADP is currently 44.37, a mark that outweighs what he has accomplished thus far in his career.  Granted, he has shown speed (at least 32 SB in each of his first three seasons) but what else can we really expect?

  • He is not going to hit for power, with just 11 career HR and a groundball rate of 57.5%.
  • He hits near the top of the order, so RBI aren’t going to be there.
  • He should score runs, but 100 is probably his ceiling hitting in the second spot.  You have to keep in mind that he may have to give himself up to advance Ian Kinsler and help produce a run, something a leadoff hitter rarely has to worry about.

Is there potential for him to improve on his .271 career average?  Absolutely, but can we reasonably expect him to suddenly become a .300 hitter?  That’s what he would need to do, and that’s a risk I am not about to make with a fourth round pick.

You can argue that, if he could keep it together for an entire season, he could be a 45+ SB threat.  Again, is that a gamble you are willing to take?  Dee Gordon has the potential to steal just as many, if not significantly more, bases than Andrus and he is going 100 picks later.  There’s just not enough there to justify selecting him at this spot.

2) Derek Jeter – New York Yankees
His name value alone is going to drive him up draft boards, but we all know that he is not the same player that he once was.  He’s coming off one of his worst professional years, having hit .297 with 6 HR, 61 RBI, 84 R and 16 SB.  Yes, hitting atop the Yankees order you would expect better numbers and the potential to push 100 R, but can we say for certain that Jeter will remain on top all year long?

Now 37-years old, Brett Gardner’s got a significant advantage in the speed department and could be a more dynamic sparkplug for the Yankees offense.  Seeing him take over at the top will either send Jeter to hitting second or ninth.  Regardless, seeing him return to his “normal” numbers would be a longshot. 

3) Rafael Furcal – St. Louis Cardinals
Time and time again owners who have rolled the dice on Furcal have been burned by him missing time due to injury.  In the past four years he’s had more than 383 AB just once (613 in ’09).  Even if he played full-time in ’11, do we really think he would’ve done enough to justify using him?  In 333 AB he hit .231 and stole just 9 bases.  He’s never going to be a power hitter so, if he’s not going to be a lock to steal 30+ bases, he’s a waste of a spot.  I’d much rather roll the dice late on a shortstop with upside (Cliff Pennington, Zack Cozart) as opposed to a player that easily could fail to produce.

4) Yunel Escobar – Toronto Blue Jays
It has nothing to do with where he’s being drafted or anything like that.  It’s just, in my opinion, he doesn’t bring nearly enough to the table to have him on my roster.  He’s not a source of stolen bases.  He’s never hit more than 14 HR.  He’s a career .289 hitter.  He’s a solid player, but he’s one that is better in real life than he is for fantasy owners.

When I am going to draft someone I want him to bring something to the table.  Escobar is average all across the board, but he doesn’t excel anywhere. 

5) Emilio Bonifacio – Florida Marlins
I included him as a third baseman to avoid, and the same argument holds water when you are going to consider him as a shortstop.  Like I said previously, if he was going to be hitting leadoff he would have avoided all lists, but hitting second in the order is not conducive for his game.

How often is he going to be allowed to run when Hanley Ramirez or Mike Stanton is at the plate?  How often is he going to give himself up to advance Jose Reyes, meaning he’s not on base and can’t score runs.  Then you mix in his potential regression thanks to a high strikeout rate (20.1%), inflated BABIP (.372) and lack of power and there is a ton of risk involved.

What are your thoughts on these five players?  Will you be targeting any of them on draft day?  Why or why not?

***** Order the Rotoprofessor 2012 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide, complete with updates from January through the start of the season, for just $6! As an added bonus, if you purchase by 3/15 you will be entered to win a Michael Pineda autographed baseball! To place your order click here. *****

Make sure to check out our look at other players to avoid for the 2012 campaign:


  1. Art Vandelay says:

    I agree RP on andrus, i never have understood the love for him, no power, not that great of an average, possibly 100 runs and 35-40 sb’s? Defly not h2h friendly, roto a little more so, but even then why take that if I can get a 25-15 hunter pence off the board then and fill my OF? I’d rather take JJ Hardy in the 13th round and get 20 HR’s outta my SS. There’s just too many more valuable players around when he goes off the board. Don’t reach to just fill a position.

    • jmax says:

      Once again I agree. Today on MDC I got into it w a couple of guys after Andrus went 38th overall. Mr. Know-It-All then proceeded to take Hosmer with his 4th round pick. Im a Hosmer fan too. I picked him up last yr 2 weeks before his call up. Bur who knew so many other drafters would stick up for the guy when I asked if he was serious. Could be another profitable year……

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *