Fantasy Throwdown: Jason Heyward vs. Adam Jones: Which Emerging Outfielder Offers More 2013 Value?

When you are looking at Jason Heyward and Adam Jones you are talking about two of the emerging outfielders in the league. Entering 2012 there were definite concerns surrounding Heyward (i.e. his ability to hit for power), while Jones was coming off a career year (25 HR, 12 SB). A year later Jones showed an additional gear while Heyward is coming off a breakout campaign. So who is the better draft day selectionfor 2013? Lets take a look:

Heyward – 27 HR
Jones – 32 HR

Heyward – Over his first two professional seasons Heyward had shown a propensity to drive the ball into the ground, with groundball rates of 55.1% and 53.9%. It is hard to hit for a lot of power doing that, bringing the valid concerns on if he would develop into anything more than a 20ish home run hitter. However, in his third season, Heyward seemed to figure it out.

He lowered his groundball rate to 44.0% and, in turn, the power flourished. Not only did he set a career high in home runs, but in doubles (30) and triples (6) as well. Given his 16.9% HR/FB, which was right along the lines of his career mark of 16.0%, there is no reason to think that he can’t at least maintain last years break out. In fact, seeing a 30+ HR campaign from him in 2013 is extremely realistic.

Jones – Like Heyward he set a career high in home runs, as well as doubles (39) in 2012. The difference is that his HR/FB, which as been trending up, reached 18.8% (career mark of 14.1%). If you think he can maintain that level or not will determine if you think he can replicate his success.

He actually saw his power dip in the second half (12 HR), based on a much more believable 15.8% HR/FB (he was at 21.3% in the first half). The former is probably the more believable number for fantasy owners to expect, meaning he likely is more of a consistent 24-27 HR threat.

Edge – Heyward by a hair, but this could easily be a draw

Heyward – .269
Jones – .287

Heyward – His problem is his ability to make contact (23.3% in ’12), because he hit the ball reasonably hard (19.3% line drive rate) and posted a realistic BABIP (.319). He had been right around 20.5% over his first two seasons, so there is the potential for an improvement. If that happens, you would anticipate an average in the mid-.270s, with some upside.

Jones – Even if you want to claim that his 21.5% line drive rate is unsustainable (he hasn’t been above 17.8% since becoming an every day player), he has been n the .280s each of the past three seasons (and is a career .278 hitter). It’s hard to expect anything less, especially with a consistently sold strikeout rate (18.3% or better in three of the past four years).

Edge – Jones, due to more stability

Stolen Bases:
Heyward – 21
Jones – 16

Heyward – We knew he had this type of potential, so it was nice to see him actually post this type of number. I wouldn’t expect too much more than a low 20s campaign, but that certainly is enough with his other assets.

Jones – We have been hearing about 20/20 potential for Jones, but last season was the first time he stole more than 12 bases in a Major League season. How can we expect anything more?

Edge – Heyward

Heyward – 82
Jones – 82

Heyward – He spent about half of 2012 hitting third in the lineup (328 AB), but that’s should be his full-time spot in 2013.  It is possible that the addition of Justin Upton pushes him to the #2 spot, but that seems unlikely to me.  Heyward is coming off a much better season, is home grown and has just as much upside. Expect 90+ to be a minimum.

Jones – Like Heyward, Jones should be in a prime Lineup spot to drive in runs (most likely third or fourth). The question is, can Nate McLouth continue his renaissance and give Jones ample opportunities to drive him in? Jones hit exclusively third or fourth last season, mustering only 82 RBI. While there is upside, I wouldn’t expect it to be a major jump.

Edge – Heyward due to his upside and better lineup

Heyward – 93
Jones – 103

Heyward – He scored 93 runs despite hitting fifth and sixth a total of 200 times last season. Now, imagine what he can do with Freddie Freeman and probably Justin Upton hitting behind him all season?

Jones – He scored a ton of runs, but can we expect Chris Davis to have the same type of power season? A regression there is going to hurt Jones.

Edge – Probably a tie

At this point, while Jones is coming off a career year, it is hard to imagine him repeating it. Whether it is his own regression, or in the supporting cast around him, it s easy to imagine the numbers coming down across the board. On the flip side, Heyward showed 20/20 skills and, hitting third full-time, should go at least 90/90 with 100/100 upside. Outside of average (and that isn’t even too far off), he is either the equal or better than Jones. In other words, he is an easy choice of the two.

What are your thoughts? Which outfielder would you rather have? Why?

***** There are now two ways to purchase the Rotoprofessor 2013 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide ( complete with expanded rankings, prospect lists, Top 25 sleepers and so much more)!!

1) Order the guide for $6 2) Make a $10 deposit at FanDuel (if you have never deposited before) and get an additional $10 to play with and the Rotoprofessor Draft Guide Free!

Click here for details!!*****

Make sure to check out all of our 2013 Player Comparisons:


  1. David says:

    I have to choose between Adam Jones and Billy Butler for my final keeper in my keeper league. I am siding towards Butler. Who should I keep between those two?

  2. Frank says:

    I agree with your assessment. I’m nitpicking here, but Heyward will probably wind up batting 2nd in the lineup this season as opposed to 3rd.

    • Rotoprofessor says:

      That’s definitely fair and not impossible. It all depends on if they want to his B.J. Upton ago the lineup, or in the middle. If Upton is leading off (which may make the most sense), then Simmons will slide into the #2 hole keeping Heyward third.

      Time will tell how they decide to line it up, though!

  3. bravos says:

    So Fredi already came out and said j.upton is hitting third and heyward do you see that affecting their fantasy value?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *