Fantasy Crystal Ball: Why Jean Segura Is Unlikely To Maintain His Early Season Success

We all knew Jean Segura had talent, but he has far exceeded any expectations thus far. Through Monday all he had done was hit .368 with 6 HR, 16 RBI, 20 R and 13 SB in 136 AB. For as great as he has been, we all know that we have to be realistic. Chances are he is going to regress. The only question is how far (all stats are courtesy of Fangraphs unless otherwise noted).

Segura has done a great job of making contact, with a 12.8% strikeout rate. It’s marginally better than we should’ve expected, considering his 13.9% mark in the Majors in 2012 and 13.8% mark in 364 AB with the Angels Double-A affiliate. It has increased in May (14.0%), which would’ve been closer to expectations.

He has also done a good job of hitting the ball well, with a 21.1% line drive rate. Couple that with his speed and you would expect an above average BABIP. However, his .393 mark is a bit excessive.

That said, it is far from a guarantee that he continues making such good contact. According to Minor League Central (which has his current Major League line drive rate higher, at 25.4%), his minor league line drive rate since 2011 is 15.0% (and was 16.9% last season). While seeing him mature is to be expected, this represents a mighty hefty improvement.

It’s possible that pitchers are still learning how to pitch to him and a major correction is coming. Of course, it’s also possible that at 23-years old he as taken a major step forward in his development as a player. The truth probably lies somewhere between the two, but one thing we do know is that his average is going to take a hit (and possibly a substantial one).

ROS Expectation – .285+

He’s hit 6 HR, which isn’t a ton, but he’s not a power hitter. He has never hit more than 10 HR in a season and is currently sporting a 50.9% groundball rate. The fact is, while it has been a nice bonus, it is impossible to think he’s going to maintain this type of pace.

ROS Expectation – 8-10 HR

Segura can run and, seeing him hit towards the top of the order, it’s not a surprise that the stolen bases are coming. Last season he totaled 44 SB and had 50 back in 2010. While he may slow down a little bit, there’s no reason to think he can’t keep on chugging along. That said, hitting in front of Ryan Braun could keep him planted at first base a little bit more often than we’d like.

ROS Expectation – 20+ SB

Segura has battled injuries before, but as long as he can stay healthy there is a lot to like. I would expect pitchers to adjust, leading to a significant drop in the average. I also wouldn’t expect him to come close to this power pace. That said, even if he performs at my baseline numbers for the rest of the season there is a lot to like (especially since he should continue scoring runs).

He’s not an automatic sell high candidate, especially in keeper leagues. He has the potential to be a Top 7 or 8 SS, or better, for years to come. In yearly formats, though, his value won’t likely get any greater than it is right now.


  1. JT says:

    Thanks, Great work, Does this look about right in the SS pecking order (from a keeper point of view)

    • KB says:

      If injuries aren’t factored in (which Im assuming they aren’t considering you have Tulo #1) then for me Top 10 would be:


      Tulo is far and away #1. Reyes was off to a sensational start before his injury, as was Hanley. For me, Castro still hasn’t taken the next step or the same step that Desmond has the past 2 years now.

  2. EL BURRO says:

    Love Segura. THink he’s a sneaky top 8-10 SS the rest of the way…

    Unrelated, but would appreciate your take.

    In a deep 14 team, H2H, 6×6 (OPS) mixed, redraft league –Danny Espinosa just became available.

    I realize Espinosa has been disgusting to date, and he may be masking an injury still… Nevertheless, would you drop Gyorko or Alexei for him? Gyorko’s park and line-up are not sexy, to say the least. That said, he has one of the best LD% in all of MLB (29.3%), which usually signals he’s due for a correction for the better…Alexei has just finally started hitting/ running and seems to like the #2 spot. Plus, it hasn’t quite warmed up in Chicago, when balls start to fly outta there. Are either of them worth a drop for Espinosa? Also in my head is the fact that Lombardozzi and a AAA , Anthony Rendon are both there if he struggles any more. Still the upside power/speed combo is tempting. And it’s technically a free “add”.

    Here is rest of my MI:

    Martin Prado – SS/2B/3B (currently my 2B)
    Alexei Ramirez – SS (currently my SS)
    Jedd Gyorko – 2B/3B (currently my MI)

    Appreciate your thoughts….

  3. Rotoprofessor says:

    JT – I like Zobrist more than Segura, but those are the names that are going to be in the mix (along with Rollins/Escobar like KB said). The bottom line is that he’s going to be a solid option moving forward.

    El Burro – Is there someone else you can drop? With how he’s struggling it’s hard to pick him up to throw him right into your lineup. It’s a much better add if you can stash him on your bench until he starts waking up.

  4. RL says:

    I think Segura is a tremendous pickup so far. Someone dropped him in my keeper league and I snatched him up, but others have noticed his value, which brings this question, if you don’t mind answering.

    I’ve been offered Prince Fielder, James Shields, a fifth round tradable pick for Edwin Encarnacion, Segura, and a late round pick (near the bottom portion of the draft). I already have Jose Reyes, but his injury scares me regarding the future.

    Thanks and I’d appreciate what you’d have to say

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *