Two-Start Options: Week 9 (May 31 – June 6)

It’s time to look at the potential two-start options for the upcoming fantasy week.  If I have someone rated as a three, four or five-star option, they are someone I would definitely use.  A two-star option is someone who is borderline, but I’d strongly lean against it unless I have no other options.  The one-star options are an absolutely not scenario.

So, with that said, let’s take a look at the players available to you this week:

Five-Star Options:

  • Ubaldo Jimenez – Colorado Rockies – @ Col, @ Ari
  • Tim Lincecum – San Francisco Giants – vs. Col, @ Pit
  • Justin Verlander – Detroit Tigers – vs. Oak, @ KC

Four-Star Options:

  • Chad Billinglsey – Los Angeles Dodgers – vs. Ari, vs. Atl
  • Matt Garza – Tampa Bay Rays – @ Tor, @ Tex
  • Tommy Hanson – Atlanta Braves – vs. Phi, @ LAD
  • Tim Hudson – Atlanta Braves – vs. Phi, @ LAD
  • Roy Oswalt – Houston Astros – vs. Was, vs. CHC

Three-Star Options:

  • Nick Blackburn – Minnesota Twins – @ Sea, @ Oak
  • Mark Buehrle – Chicago White Sox – vs. Tex, vs. Cle
  • John Ely – Los Angeles Dodgers – vs. Ari, vs. Atl
  • Jamie Garcia – St. Louis Cardinals – vs. Cin, vs. Mil
  • John Lackey – Boston Red Sox – vs. Oak, @ Bal
  • Francisco Liriano – Minnesota Twins – @ Sea, @ Oak
  • Brett Myers – Houston Astros – vs. Was, vs. CHC
  • Ricky Nolasco – Florida Marlins – vs. Mil, @ NYM
  • Andy Pettitte – New York Yankees – vs. Cle, @ Tor
  • Ervin Santana – Los Angeles Angels – @ KC, @ Sea

Two-Star Options:

  • Bronson Arroyo – Cincinnati Reds – @ Stl, @ Was
  • Joe Blanton – Philadelphia Phillies – @ Atl, vs. SD
  • Jeremy Bonderman – Detroit Tigers – vs. Cle, @ KC
  • Trevor Cahill – Oakland Athletics – @ Det, vs. Min
  • Doug Fister – Seattle Mariners – vs. Min, vs. LAA
  • Gio Gonzalez – Oakland Athletics – @ Bos, vs. Min
  • Rich Harden – Texas Rangers – @ CWS, vs. TB
  • Luke Hochevar – Kansas City Royals – vs. LAA, vs. Det
  • Joel Pineiro – Los Angeles Angels – @ KC, @ Sea
  • Hisanori Takahashi – New York Mets – @ SD, vs. Fla
  • Jason Vargas – Seattle Mariners – vs. Min, vs. LAA
  • Javier Vazquez – New York Yankees – vs. Bal, @ Tor

One-Star Options:

  • Luis Atilano – Washington Nationals – @ Hou, vs. Cin
  • Brian Bannister – Kansas City Royals – vs. LAA, vs. Det
  • Dave Bush – Milwaukee Brewers – @ Fla, @ Stl
  • Kevin Correia – San Diego Padres – vs. NYM, @ Phi
  • Rodrigo Lopez – Arizona Diamondbacks – @ LAD, vs. Col
  • Brian Matusz – Baltimore Orioles – @ NYY, vs. Bos
  • Brandon Morrow – Toronto Blue Jays – vs. TB, vs. NYY
  • Chris Narveson – Milwaukee Brewers – @ Fla, @ Stl
  • Ross Ohlendorf – Pittsburgh Pirates – vs. CHC, vs. SF
  • Nate Robertson – Florida Marlins – vs. Mil, @ NYM
  • Craig Stammen – Washington Nationals – @ Hou, vs. Cin
  • Mitch Talbot – Cleveland Indians – @ NYY, @ CWS
  • Jake Westbrook – Cleveland Indians – @ Det, @ CWS

Scheduling Notes:

  • Will the Mets use a Wednesday off day to avoid needing a fifth starter?  If they do, that will mean two starts for Mike Pelfrey.  He’s a must use option as it is, but if he gets starts against the Padres and Marlins, he’d be a four-star option.
  • It is not yet known who will start on Monday for the Cubs, with Tom Gorzelanny or Randy Wells being named options.  Even with solid matchups (@ Pit, @ Hou), do you trust either right now?  Whichever it is would be put into the two-star options.

Thoughts:

  • Justin Verlander is not Tim Lincecum or Ubaldo Jimenez, but we all know the type of pitcher he is after April and he has two fantastic matchups.  That’s enough to bring him up to a five-star option for this week.
  • I don’t think anyone would have expected John Ely to develop into a must use option, but he’s given up two earned runs or less in each of his last five starts (3-1 over that span).  If you can keep the Dodgers in games, you are going to get an opportunity for wins.  The matchups aren’t the best, but he’s still worth rolling the dice on given his recent performance.
  • We all know that Mark Buehrle has struggled, but he hasn’t allowed a run in his last 10.1 innings (he was ejected in his last outing after just 2.1 innings).  We also know that he’s better then he’s shown.  The Rangers are a tough matchup, but he’s pitched well against them over his career (11-4 with a 3.07 ERA) and then has an easier matchup with the Indians.  With that in mind, he’s worth using in all formats.
  • Nick Blackburn has won his last five starts, including two matchups with the Yankees.  Over that span he’s allowed 3 ER or less in each start, while going at least 7 innings.  He doesn’t offer much in strikeouts, but when you are pitching that well to go along with those matchups, he’s worth using in all formats.
  • Jeremy Bonderman has solid matchups, but does anyone really trust him?  I know he’s been pitching fairly well (4 ER over his last 4 stats), but he has just 1 win over that time.  That’s what helps to differentiate him from Blackburn.
  • Brian Matusz and Brandon Morrow have a ton of upside.  We all know it.  However, with those matchups, it is impossible to use either of them this week.

What are your thoughts?  Who have I ranked too high?  Who do you think will outperform my rankings?

To view the previous article, click here.

5 comments

  1. Frank says:

    Thank you for the time and effort you pit forth in publishing your assessments and reviews.
    Your information is thoughtful, comprehensive and timely; not the regurgitated duplication I have viewed on other sites.

  2. pat says:

    I need a third closer for my team and am thinking of offering a trade to a team loaded with RPs and a weak outfield. How does this sound?
    Giving: Dan Uggla, Josh Hamilton, Cole Hamels
    Getting: Brandon Phillips, Carlos Marmol, Roy Oswalt

  3. Bermuda Triangles says:

    My league site (on CBS) shows Ely as a 1 start pitcher – going wednesday… thoughts?

    Also, Pelfrey? I have him going against @SD and vs FLA… 3 stars?

    Thanks!

  4. Rotoprofessor says:

    I’d mark Pelfrey as a 4-star option. He’s been that good this season and those are favorable matchups.

    According to mlb.com, Ely is still set to go on Tuesday, so he would be a two-start option, and one worth rolling the dice with.

  5. Rotoprofessor says:

    Pat, I don’t love that offer.

    Uggla & Hamels for Phillips & Oswalt is nearly a wash in my mind, so that means you are basically trading Hamilton for Marmol. Hamilton is an injury risk, but still, if you are trading him for a closer I would think you could get a more dependable option then Marmol in exchange.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>