Trade Deadline Fallout: Jhonny Peralta To The Detroit Tigers

The Detroit Tigers have acquired Jhonny Peralta (and cash) from the Cleveland Indians for minor league pitcher Giovanni Soto, according to the team’s official Twitter feed.

The Tigers Get:
They have been beaten up with injuries recently, especially on the infield, with both Brandon Inge and Carlos Guillen being placed on the DL.  However, how big of an upgrade is Peralta over Scott Sizemore?  Certainly enough to justify the move, though Sizemore could still have value (that’s a story for another day).

Peralta has struggled this season, hitting .246 with 7 HR, 43 RBI and 37 R.  He is carrying a career worst BABIP, however, at .284, so there certainly is potential upside there.  He is just a career .264 hitter, however, so it’s not like that he will take a huge step forward, but he certainly could be usable.

The power has seemingly disappeared the past two seasons with 18 HR total.  He’s only two years removed from a 23 HR season and has enjoyed three 20+ HR years.  The fly balls are a pitiful 33.9% in ’10, compared to a career mark of 45.5%.  At 28-years old, it’s impossible to think that he simply just lost his power.  He does have 23 doubles, so it is possible that a change of scenery helps.

Don’t underestimate the idea of moving from a losing environment to a pennant race, either.  While that is not the sole reason for his struggles, it certainly wouldn’t be a surprise to see him improve his play significantly.

For now he will assume third base duties, with Inge out for around a month.  Once Inge returns, if Peralta is hitting he is not going to be put on the bench.  It’s possible that he sees time at DH, with Johnny Damon playing the outfield.  Also, he easily could see time at shortstop, where Danny Worth and Ramon Santiago are currently playing.

The bottom line is that 3B is a shallow position and there is some upside in Peralta.  I wouldn’t do anything drastic to get him, but if you have an expendable piece on your bench and need help at third, he’s certainly worth the flier.

The Indians Get:
Soto is just 19-years old and playing at Single-A. In 16 starts he’s gone 6-6 with a 2.61 ERA and 76 Ks over 82.2 innings.  Clearly, the lefty has some potential, currently second in the Midwest League in ERA, but he is a long way from making an impact.

What are your thoughts on the deal?  Could Peralta be usable?

Make sure to check out our other trade analysis:

Keep checking for all the fantasy fallout from the deadline deals!

One comment

  1. RY says:

    Seems like a desperate move by the Tigers. They have played against Peralta enough to be privy to the holes in his swing. They probably lost out on the Yunel Escobar raffle.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *