Week 3 Rankings (2016): Top 15 Kickers

by Ray Kuhn

If it seems that there is no such thing as picking the wrong kicker, that is the truth. (at least until said kicker misses a field goal or an extra point). Efficiency is the name of the game, as is scoring (the over/under for a game is usually a helpful source of information). That is also a good way to find value at the kicker position, as it is often a good way to save money in DFS where kickers are still required. Let’s take a look at how the kickers rank for this week:

  1. Stephen Gostkowski – New England Patriots – vs. Houston
  2. Adam Vinatieri – Indianapolis Colts – vs. San Diego
  3. Dan Bailey – Dallas Cowboys – vs. Chicago
  4. Matt Bryant – Atlanta Falcons – at New Orleans
  5. Mason Crosby – Green Bay Packers – vs. Detroit
  6. Justin Tucker – Baltimore Ravens – at Jacksonville
  7. Steven Hauschka – Seattle Seahawks – vs. San Francisco
  8. Josh Lambo – San Diego Chargers – at Indianapolis
  9. Graham Gano – Carolina Panthers – vs. Minnesota
  10. Josh Brown – New York Giants – vs. Washington
  11. Chandler Catanzaro – Arizona Cardinals – at Buffalo
  12. Chris Boswell – Pittsburgh Steelers – at Philadelphia
  13. Cairo Santos – Kansas City Chiefs – vs. New York Jets
  14. Will Lutz – New Orleans Saints – vs. Atlanta
  15. Nick Novak – Houston Texans – at New England


  • I think it is safe to assume that we won’t know until game time on Thursday who is starting at quarterback in New England. What we do know is that regardless of who is under center, their offense will likely be limited. It also doesn’t help hat they are facing a tough defense in Houston. That should lead to an increase in opportunities for the ever successful and efficient Stephen Gostkowski. Through the first two weeks of the season he actually isn’t perfect (4 of 5 on field goal attempts but he has made all seven extra points), but he can be counted on more than most.
  • The Saints are back at home in the dome, and as of Tuesday night they had the highest over/under of any game (53.5) while coming in as three point favorites. That brings my attention to rookie kicker Will Lutz. He made the Saints this summer as an u-drafted free agent, and he hasn’t had the smoothest of starts to his career. Thus far, he has missed three of his seven field goal attempts, but two came in his debut and were from beyond 50 yards. It is a good sign that Lutz made both of his attempts from 40 to 49 yards and is perfect on his five extra point attempts.
  • Using the same logic, Josh Lambo of the Chargers (51.5) is worth considering. San Diego faces quite the hospitable defense in the Colts, and they get to do it in a dome. Lambo has only attempted four field goals this season, making three, but is perfect on his eight extra points. With the Chargers now without Danny Woodhead, along with Keenan Allen, their offense might stall a little more often in the red zone.
  • Josh Brown showed no ill effects from missing the first week of the season due to suspension. He did miss one long distance field goal, but he converted on his other three attempts and if you are looking to replace a kicker, he is worth a look as he was likely undrafted in the majority of leagues.

Make sure to check out all of our Week 3 rankings:

Week 3 Rankings (2016): Top 50 Wide Receivers
Week 3 Rankings (2016): Top 40 Running Backs


  1. Gern says:

    Hey Prof,
    Thanks for the Tyrell Williams advice earlier. So here’s my dilemma. If Peterson is out for the year and D. Williams drops off the fantasy map next week when Bell returns I’m left with one healthy RB for week 4 (Bernard, with Foster and Martin out). Ware is on the waiver wire (and Sims in a FA), but I’m #10 on the wire after picking up Foster this week and wouldn’t know if it went through until Saturday. If Peterson is placed on IR after surgery tomorrow I might pick up Sims and then use him as the waiver wire switch if Ware is still there.

    Another thing I’m puzzling through is whether to float Aaron Rogers as trade bait (he’s on a bye in week 4 and I have Brady returning week 5. Also Matt Ryan’s available on waivers). Or Rogers and Williams (and his big projected points this week) for a RB1 and a WR2/3. I was just curious whether you think I’ve lost it early in the season and should take a stiff drink or whether I should explore my options. If I do send out the message to the league that Rogers is on the trading block what you think might be a fair return? I’ve reached out to folks about Charles and Gurley over the past few days, but with few healthy options on the roster I’ve had no takers. Thanks again as always.

    Here’s my current team:

    QB: Rogers/Brady
    RB: Peterson/Williams/Martin/Bernard/Foster
    WR: Green/J. Matthews/Edelman/T. Williams
    TE: Ebron/Eifert
    K: Gostkowski
    D: KC

Leave a Reply to Rotoprofessor Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *