Week 5 Rankings (2016): Top 40 Running Backs

by Ray Kuhn

We are now a quarter of the way through the season, and there are just as many questions as we had before things got started. In fact, things might be worse now thanks to various injuries. What helps is that we at least are starting to get a better idea of who the under and over performers are and what to expect from each team. Let’s jump right into the Week 5 rankings as we kick off the second quarter of the season:

  1. Le’Veon Bell – Pittsburgh Steelers – vs. New York Jets
  2. David Johnson – Arizona Cardinals – at San Francisco
  3. DeMarco Murray – Tennessee Titans – at Miami
  4. Melvin Gordon – San Diego Chargers – at Oakland
  5. LeSean McCoy – Buffalo Bills – at Los Angeles Rams
  6. Ezekiel Elliot – Dallas Cowboys – vs. Cincinnati
  7. C.J. Anderson – Denver Broncos – vs. Atlanta
  8. Todd Gurley – Los Angeles Rams – vs. Buffalo
  9. Carlos Hyde – San Francisco 49ers – vs. Arizona
  10. Devonta Freeman – Atlanta Falcons – at Denver
  11. Lamar Miller – Houston Texans – at Minnesota
  12. Jordan Howard – Chicago Bears – at Indianapolis
  13. Eddie Lacy – Green Bay Packers – vs. New York Giants
  14. Frank Gore – Indianapolis Colts – vs. Chicago Bears
  15. Terrance West – Baltimore Ravens – vs. Washington
  16. LeGarrette Blount – New England Patriots – at Cleveland
  17. Jerick McKinnon – Minnesota Vikings – vs. Houston
  18. Isaiah Crowell – Cleveland Browns – vs. New England
  19. Latavius Murray – San Diego Chargers – vs. San Diego
  20. Jeremy Hill – Cincinnati Bengals – at Dallas
  21. Theo Riddick – Detroit Lions – vs. Philadelphia
  22. Charles Sims – Tampa Bay Buccaneers – at Carolina
  23. Duke Johnson – Cleveland Browns – vs. New England
  24. Matt Forte – New York Jets – at Pittsburgh
  25. Matt Jones – Washington Redskins – at Baltimore
  26. Ryan Mathews – Philadelphia Eagles – at Detroit
  27. James White – New England Patriots – at Cleveland
  28. Darren Sproles – Philadelphia Eagles – at Detroit
  29. Fozzy Whitaker – Carolina Panthers – vs. Tampa Bay
  30. Giovani Bernard – Cincinnati Bengals – at Dallas
  31. Bilal Powell – New York Jets – at Pittsburgh
  32. Orleans Darkwa – New York Giants – at Green Bay
  33. DeAndre Washington – Oakland Raiders – vs. San Diego
  34. Tevin Coleman – Atlanta Falcons – at Denver
  35. Chris Thompson – Washington Redskins – at Baltimore
  36. Cameron Artis-Payne – Carolina Panthers – vs. Tampa Bay
  37. Matt Asiata – Minnesota Vikings – vs. Houston
  38. Derrick Henry – Tennessee Titans – at Miami
  39. Bobby Rainey – New York Giants – at Green Bay
  40. Jay Ajayi – Miami Dolphins – vs. Tennessee


  • Entering the season one of the backfields that was in the most flux was Baltimore’s. Things have gotten a little clearer with the release, for the second time, of Justin Forsett, and we still have another week or two before Kenneth Dixon truly becomes a factor. That means for the second straight week Terrance West will have a starring role for the Ravens. Last week at home against the Raiders he carried the ball 21 times for 113 yards and a touchdown. On the season he is averaging 4.3 yards per carry, but it is clear that he is finding his groove for Baltimore which is why Forsett was was phased out. With just four receptions West isn’t going to be a factor in the passing game, but with that kind of production on the ground there is nothing wrong with that. This week West faces the Redskins, who allowed Isaiah Crowell to rush for 120 yards and a touchdown on 16 carries last week.
  • What do we make of Matt Forte for this week? After racking up 59 touches in the first two weeks of the season, a far heavier workload than any expected or projected, Forte never really got going against Kansas City in Week 3. After averaging 4.3 yards per carry on 15 carries against the Chiefs, Forte gained just 27 yards on 14 carries last week against Seattle before departing for x-rays. Nothing else is known about his health as of Tuesday night, but there has to be some cause for concern. Forte caught five passes the first week of the season, but he has caught just two passes a game since then. Bilal Powell has taken on a greater role as of late, and he caught six passes for 54 yards (nine targets) on Sunday while gaining 26 yards on four carries. Forte is not a running back I would target this week if there are better options, and at the very least his status needs to be monitored. Powell is a borderline FLEX option, especially in PPR leagues, but depending on Forte’s status, he could be a running back to utilize.
  • Did anyone expect DeMarco Murray to be a Top 5 running back through the first four weeks of the season? If you did you would be in the minority, but the same would also be true if you expect Murray to continue on that pace for the rest of the season. He gained another 95 yards Sunday on 25 carries, but he also found the end zone two more times while catching two passes for 24 yards. So far he is averaging 5.2 yards per carry on 66 carries while also catching 19 passes for 156 yards. At some point Murray will likely slow down, he also has a track record of success and at age 28 he is showing he still has plenty left in the tank. There is enough here for Murray to be an RB1 for the remainder of the season, and he has another nice match-up againt the Dolphins.
  • While Matt Asiata did reach the end zone on another short yardage carry, Jerick McKinnon is still the back to own while Adrian Peterson is sidelined. McKinnon also found the end zone on the ground and gained 85 yards on 18 carries. Known as a receiving threat out of the backfield, McKinnon was targeted five times and caught just three passes for 10 yards. Overall he was the better running back and touched the ball 21 times while Asiata had eight. I would look for that trend to continue.
  • Should we really be surprised about how the season has gone for Latavius Murray? After opening the season with 15 touches he has seen the total go down each week to just 10 against the Ravens last week. Murray carried the ball eight times, and gained just 19 yards, while catching two passes for five yards. On the season he does have three touchdowns, and is averaging 4.3 yards per carry on 40 carries. That pales though in comparison to the success DeAndre Washington and Jalen Richards have been having on a per carry basis. The problem is that the full transition likely won’t take place for another few weeks as Washington touched the ball just eight times, five carries and three receptions, on Sunday. He gained 46 yards on the day, and is averaging 6.4 yards per carry while Richards is at 8.5 yards on 17 carries (he had just three touches on Sunday). This week Murray could be in play for a big day as he faces the Chargers and their weak defense.
  • While Fozzy Whitaker carried the ball just three times on Sunday, for six yards, he wasn’t without value. Game flow came into play here as the Panthers were trailing all day, but Whitaker did catch all nine of his targets for 86 yards. That gives him some PPR value if you need to fill a spot due to injury or a bye week, and I would look for that to continue this week.
Week 5 Rankings (2016): Top 15 Kickers
Week 5 Rankings (2016): Top 20 Tight Ends


  1. Randy says:

    In a 10-team standard, I have Luck/Wentz, Miller/Howard/Ware/Deanglo/Smallwood; A-Rob/Cobb/Pryor/Shepard/Steve Smith; and Fleener/Eifert. First, I have to drop someone for a K, who would you drop? Second, Deangelo and Ware have been great but it’s hard having both on a team w/ roster limits not knowing their future role (Ware) or a lottery ticket. Trades aside, would you drop either for Jennings, Powell, James White, Dixon, or Duke? Thanks!

  2. haggy says:

    OK Prof. Got Lacy,D.Johnson,J.Howard,J.Charles,and S.Ware . Who would you use for trade bait. Need WR’s.

  3. Randy says:

    Who would you rather have as your last RB in a standard league? Dwayne Washington, Smallwood, Rashad Jennings, or James White? Also, Who would you drop for a kicker out of Julius Thomas (on bye, have Hunter); the RB above (have Miller/Crowell/Gore/Deangelo/Howard), Deangelo (trading wont’ happen), Enunwa or Cobb (have Julio, Evans), or one of my LBs (have Kwon and Zach Brown; only start 1 but saw Brown’s numbers and know Kwon is on bye next week, so was thinking ahead). Thanks!

  4. Chris says:

    Professor would you drop layouts Murray to pick up kenneth Dixon since Murray is losing value

  5. LK says:

    Would you drop Ware and/or Enunwa for West and/or Dixon? Looking more at keep away or trade bait value than anyone I’ll be playing soon, other RBs Shady DJohnson Gordon Howard C-Mike Crowell, WRs Cooper Cobb M.Jones Jr. Decker Pryor


  6. Randy – DeAngelo would be my first drop, so dump him for a K the. Consider adding someone. As for the flier, I guess Jennings

    Haggy – Charles/Ware if possible

    Chris – Nah, not like Dixon is going to carry load himself. Idea
    Ly stash both

    LK – if it’s just for stashing, Enunwa easy cut. Ware a bit tougher but makes sense

  7. dodge10 says:

    the picking are slim since my quarterback carson palmer went down with a concussion and he will not be playing tommorrow night. who do I go with his backup drew stanton, cody kessler or blaine gabbert.

  8. WDYT says:

    With Latavis Murray injured, WDYT about swapping him out of DeAndre Washington …. Will bulk of carries go to him or Jalean Richard? Or just leave this mess for Duke Johnson or James White? 10 team standard

    As always thanks for your insights

    • It’s still going to be a timeshare, though Washington would have the highest upside. That said, easy to imagine those guys failing and Murray still has highest upside when healthy. All depends on need

  9. Matthew Summerlin says:

    Hi Prof,

    I asked you earlier in the week about starting Cooper over Hopkins. You favored Hopkins. Now I’m reading that Jason Verrett is out with ACL injury. Do you still favor Hopkins over Cooper now that Verrett is done?


  10. darrick pitynski says:

    Professor would you trade away forte fir mark ingram

  11. darrick says:

    Hey professor, i just received a trade offer for forte. Would you trade away forte for ingram

  12. Andy says:

    If you need 2 backup ROS which 2 will you keep? case standard and case PPR

    Rashing Jenning, Charles Sims, DeAndrew Washington, Dwayne Washington, Kenneth Dixon

    Can you arrange from Best > ok . ?


    • Jennings is top choice.

      Dixon would be #2

      After that it becomes a bit of a mess. I’d go Washington (OAK), Washington (DET) and then Sims, but they are pretty interchangable

  13. STEVEN says:

    pick 2 cj anderson, jordan howard and lamar miller

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *