Start ‘Em or Sit ‘Em (2017): Week 5: Carson Wentz, Marshawn Lynch, Latavius Murray & More

by Eric Stashin (aka The Rotoprofessor)

Trying to decide who you should start or sit this week? Let’s take a look at a few potential decisions owners have and try to sort through them:


Start – Carson Wentz – Philadelphia Eagles – vs. Arizona

After putting up 250 yards or less in each of the past two weeks, while throwing for 1 TD per week, it would be easy to ignore Wentz.  The Cardinals are in the bottom half of the league in points allowed per week to opposing quarterbacks, and that’s despite facing the Colts and 49ers.  That’s not to say that they aren’t a talented group, but at the same time Philadelphia will have an opportunity to produce through the air.  Wentz will also be playing at home, where he played significantly better last season:

  • Home – 64.8% completion rate, 9 TD, 5 INT
  • Road – 60.4% completion rate, 7 TD, 9 INT

This would be a good opportunity to utilize Wentz, especially with the bye weeks causing trouble in setting our lineups.

Sit – Ben Roethlisberger – Pittsburgh Steelers – at Jacksonville
The Jaguars are giving up the fewest points per week against opposing quarterbacks, and that’s because they have been so porous against the run (third most points per week to opposing RB).  That should mean another Le’Veon Bell-centric attack (he took 35 carries for 144 yards and 2 TD in Week 4), and limited chances for Roethlisberger to make big plays.  He’s coming off a week where he threw for 216 yards and has a season high of 263 (back in Week 1).  Throw in that he brings no value with his legs (7 carries for -5 yards) and unless you have no other alternatives the risk far outweighs the reward.


Running Backs
Start – Marshawn Lynch – Oakland Raiders – vs. Baltimore

Lynch has been a bit of a disappointment in his return to the NFL, averaging 3.4 yards per carry over his first four games and really limping as of late (15 carries for 30 yards over the past two weeks).  Of course one of those games came against the dominant Denver defense, and Washington has been very good as well.  Things are different for Week 5, where everything seems to be working in his favor:

  • The loss of Derek Carr should lead to more rushing attempts
  • Baltimore is traveling across the country
  • Baltimore has allowed the fifth most points per week to opposing RB, including the sixth most rushing yards (455 and 3 TD)

Start – Latavius Murray – Minnesota Vikings – at Chicago
The loss of Dalvin Cook should mean an opportunity for Murray, who draws a favorable matchup in his first start.  While he’s still working his way back from his ankle injury and may not be at full strength, he should see the bulk of the early down/short yardage work.  Against a Bears’ defense that’s allowed 4 rushing TD (tied for second most in the league), there’s a good chance that he hits the ground running.  He’s not going to be a RB1, but he’s a viable RB2/must use FLEX option.

Sit – Andre Ellington – Arizona Cardinals – at Philadelphia
While it’s becoming obvious that Ellington is the best option in the Arizona backfield, that doesn’t necessarily mean that he’s going to get the bulk of the touches.  He seems destined to share things with Chris Johnson, and while he saw 14 targets in Week 4 it’s hard to imagine that being replicated as the wide receiving corps gets healthy.  Throw in that the Eagles have done a good job at stopping opposing running backs, including just 16 receptions, and Ellington is a FLEX option at best (and a riskier one at that).

Sit – D’Onta Foreman – Houston Texans – vs. Kansas City
Foreman has started eating into the touches of Lamar Miller, including 13 carries in Week 4, though he hasn’t been particularly productive.  He has 34 carries for 114 yards (3.4 yards/carry) and managed just 2 receptions (and they came in the same game).  The Chiefs also aren’t an ideal matchup, and with the potential for Deshaun Watson to be given more opportunities he’s an obvious sit.


Wide Receivers (Two-Receiver Formats)
Start – Devante Parker – Miami Dolphins – vs. Tennessee

While Parker has scored 1 TD in his first three games, he’s been targeted at least 8 times each week and has turned them into 69+ yards (18 receptions for 230 yards).  Tennessee has allowed 8 TD to opposing wide receivers, most in the league (no one else has allowed more than 6), and Parker offers the most potential to find the end zone from Miami’s receiving corps.  You could argue him as a borderline WR1.

Sit – Sammy Watkins – Los Angeles Rams – vs. Seattle
The Seahawks may not be the same defense that they once were, but they’ve still done a good job of shutting down opposing wide receivers.  That alone would scare us off from Watkins, and despite the Rams offense coming together Watkins has been targeted twice in two of the four games (16 total targets) and only has one big day (106 yards and 2 TD in Week 3 against the 49ers).  There’s far too much risk involved.


Wide Receivers (Three-Receiver Formats)
Start – Devin Funchess – Carolina Panthers – at Detroit
Kelvin Benjamin is banged up, and while he did play in Week 4 you still have to wonder if he will be limited.  Funchess has often had issues with efficiency, but he’s coming off a day where he turned 9 targets into 7 receptions, 70 yards and 2 TD.  We can’t expect the TD, but the opportunities should still be there against a defense that has allowed the eighth most receptions to opposing wide receivers through four weeks (51 receptions for 605 yards).

Sit – Marqise Lee/Allen Hurns – Jacksonville Jaguars – at Pittsburgh
The Jaguars offense is based around Leonard Fournette, with the team’s “top” two receivers combining for 29 receptions, 345 yards and 2 TD.  Couple those uninspiring numbers with a road matchup against a defense that’s allowed the fourth fewest receptions to opposing wide receivers (35 for 339 yards and 2 TD) and this duo should be avoided.


Tight Ends
Start – Hunter Henry – Los Angeles Chargers – at New York Giants

He’s the epitome of a boom or bust player thus far, and also will have to contend with Antonio Gates who could syphon off some of the tight end opportunities.  That said the Giants have been the worst defense against opposing tight ends, including 5 TD allowed.  It’s only going to take one big play for Henry to register a usable performance, and there’s a good chance he provides more than just one.

Sit – Jack Doyle – Indianapolis Colts – vs. San Francisco
The 49ers have allowed 10 receptions and 77 yards to opposing tight ends this season.  Combine that with some underwhelming performances from Doyle, who has a total of 43 yards over the past two weeks and 17 receptions, 163 yards and 0 TD overall, and this is an easy situation to avoid.  Even with the bye weeks, there are better opportunities to try and exploit.


Sources – ESPN,

This weekend only, Pre-order Rotoprofessor’s 2018 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide for just $6.25!!  Click here for the details, but don’t miss out on the best bargain in fantasy baseball preparation.

Make sure to check out all of our Week 5 rankings:

Running Backs
Wide Receivers
Tight Ends
Sunday Morning Start ‘Em or Sit ‘Em: Wayne Gallman, Davante Adams, Melvin Gordon & More
Thursday Night Start 'Em or Sit 'Em: Week 5: Chris Hogan, Doug Martin, James White & More


  1. patriots says:

    Hello Professor
    12 team standard. I have a te question. Would you drop Tyler eifert for hunter Henry for ros? My other te is jack doyle
    Thank You

  2. Mike says:

    Hi Eric, someone in my league dropped garçon. Should I drop Corey Davis for him? Also I need to drop eifert to pick up a qb bc Wilson on week 6 bye. Do u think it’s ok to drop eifert? Others on bench are Elijah McGuire, j stew, kamara and Alex Collins. Thank u!

    • Yes on the Garcon move.

      I don’t love dropping Eifert, though it does depend on who else you have. I don’t think McGuire is ever a starter, so I’m ok cutting him

      • Mike says:

        Thanks! I have ASJ. 4-0, 12 team league, standard. Russel wilson, hunt, fournette, obj, michael thomas
        Larry fitz. Lost chris Carson and stashing a bunch of rbs on bench just in case something
        Happens to starters. Ok I could drop McGuire instead of eifert. I just like McGuire and think he will
        Continue to see more and more touches, and eifert is so brittle. Thanks for advice! Have a good

  3. Dev says:

    Hello professor

    Full point PPR

    Jaron Brown or Alshon Jeffery?

    Thank you for the advices you offered…

  4. Beans says:

    What’s up Professor? Please choose 2 RB and a flex option for PPR. Jordan Howard, Mixon, Cohen, Derick Henry, Latavious Murray, Martavis Bryant or Paul Richardson?

    Please choose 1 ppr flex Ellington,Gallman, Buck Allen, Paul Richardson and John Brown? Thank you for the time

    • Question 1:
      RB – Howard/Murray
      FLEX – Mixon (I could say Cohen, but that’s putting too many eggs in one basket)

      Question 2 – I like Gallman as the high risk, high reward option. If you want to go “safe”, it’s Ellington

  5. trevor says:

    ppr-pick two:fournette, duke johnson, marshawn lynch or latvus murray

  6. trevor says:

    ppr flex will fuller or amer abdullah

    ppr flex randall cobb or latvus murray

  7. Sheldon Williamson says:

    Hey, Prof! FLEX start: Andre Ellington, Rishard Matthews, or J. D. McKissic? Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>