Week 16 Rankings (2017): Top 15 Kickers

by Ray Kuhn

I know it feels like we are beating a redundant drum, but owners of Robbie Gould certainly aren’t ignoring the kicker position. On this championship week, let’s take a look at who can help you secure those crucial points. Fantasy football never goes smoothly or as expected, and in the playoffs it feels like that is only more magnified. Here are how our options rank:

  1. Chris Boswell  – Pittsburgh Steelers – at Houston
  2. Justin Tucker – Baltimore Ravens- vs. Indianapolis
  3. Will Lutz – New Orleans Saints – vs. Atlanta
  4. Stephen Gostkowski – New England Patriots – vs. Buffalo
  5. Matt Bryant – Atlanta Falcons – at New Orleans
  6. Dan Bailey – Dallas Cowboys – vs. Seattle
  7. Harrison Butker – Kansas City Chiefs – vs. Miami
  8. Jake Elliot – Philadelphia Eagles – vs. Oakland
  9. Matt Prater – Detroit Lions – at Cincinnati
  10. Josh Lambo – Jacksonville Jaguars – at San Francisco
  11. Nick Rose – Los Angeles Chargers – at New York Jets
  12. Robbie Gould – San Francisco 49ers – vs. Jacksonville
  13. Brandon McManus – Denver Broncos – at Washington
  14. Graham Gano – Carolina Panthers – vs. Tampa Bay
  15. Phil Dawson – Arizona Cardinals – vs. New York Giants


  • Originally we were going to talk about Greg Zuerlein. At this point, there aren’t many good things left to be said about the Rams’ kicker that we haven’t said already, and this week he was facing the Titans who have allowed the most points to opposing kickers. Instead he is now out for the season with a back injury, and fantasy owners are looking for a new option at the top of this list. That brings us to Chris Boswell, who does happen to be available in about 20% of ESPN leagues. You are going to have to wait until Monday for him, when he faces the Texans on the road, but you likely will be rewarded. Houston has allowed the third most points to opposing kickers and for the season he has been a Top 5 option. So far this season Boswell has six games with three field goals or more and he has made 91.7% of his field goals while converting 29 of his 31 extra point attempts. He will likely be one of the more costlier options on the week, and playing Monday takes him out of the main DFS slate, but he is the best overall option.
  • For that situation (the main slate and value), let’s take a look at Brandon McManus who is owned in just 11.6% of ESPN leagues. We generally like to target him when he has the benefit of kicking in Denver, but the Redskins allow the fifth most points to opposing kickers. Despite missing eight field goals, McManus is perfect on all 24 of his extra point attempts and he has a track record of success. There certainly are going to be better options, but he is my streaming/budget choice for this week.
  • Efficiency. That is what Josh Lambo has given us since joining the Jaguars for Week 7. As a whole, fantasy football has not caught on as he is owned in just 26% of ESPN leagues. Lambo has missed one of his 18 field goal attempts along with just one of his 20 extra point attempts, and Jacksonville has proven to have a strong offense. In the two games in which he has only made one field goal the kicker has nine extra points, so he still returned some value.

** PRE-SALE **
This weekend only, Pre-order Rotoprofessor’s 2018 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide for just $6.25!!  Click here for the details, but don’t miss out on the best bargain in fantasy baseball preparation.

Week 16 Rankings (2017): Top 15 Defenses
Week 16 Rankings (2017): Top 50 Wide Receivers


  1. Haggy says:

    Cardinals or Redskins defense..

  2. ossqss says:

    I rode that Gould train to victory last week! Now who? I have Gould, but can get Gano, Bailey, Lambo, or Dawson. Bonus point for 40 and 50 yarders.

    Looking for something PPR flextacular again from DeDe, Perine, Wallace, Robby Anderson or Ajayai! I can never spell that right, dangit.

    Thoughts Dr. Brofessor?

    • Bailey is probably the “safest” of the group.

      As for the FLEX, Westbrook has the highest ceiling, Ajayi the “safest”. Depends on how you want to play it, but if swinging for the fences I’d go Westbrook

  3. Jason says:

    Gould also helped me win last week. This week I have
    Dawson. I’ve read really good things about Dawson for this week.
    Also, jacksonville or Chicago?

  4. Vince says:

    Any fear of rain/wind messing up tucker? I got bailey as well

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *