Week 5 Rankings (2018): Top 40 Running Backs

by Ray Kuhn

Here we are for another week of disappointments and tough, and potentially wrong, choices. Muddling through your options at running back isn’t exactly easy, but at least we have clarity, at least for the next few weeks, in Pittsburgh (Le’Veon Bell isn’t returning until Week 8) and Jacksonville (Leonard Fournette should be out a few weeks now paving the way for T.J. Yeldon) with Mark Ingram, Devonta Freeman and potentially Joe Mixon returning.

Unfortunately there are many more questions than answers, but what’s new? Let’s take a look at how this week’s options rank:

  1. Todd Gurley – LA Rams – at Seattle
  2. Alvin Kamara – New Orleans Saints – vs. Washington
  3. Christian McCaffrey – Carolina Panthers – vs. NY Giants
  4. Melvin Gordon – LA Chargers – vs. Oakland
  5. Ezekiel Elliot – Dallas Cowboys – at Houston
  6. David Johnson – Arizona Cardinals – at San Francisco
  7. James Conner – Pittsburgh Steelers – vs. Atlanta
  8. Saquon Barkley – NY Giants – at Carolina
  9. Kareem Hunt – Kansas City Chiefs – vs. Jacksonville
  10. T.J. Yeldon – Jacksonville Jaguars – at Kansas City
  11. Marshawn Lynch – Oakland Raiders – at LA Chargers
  12. Lamar Miller – Houston Texans – vs. Dallas
  13. Chris Thompson – Washington Redskins – at New Orleans
  14. Carlos Hyde – Cleveland Browns – vs. Baltimore
  15. Sony Michel – New England Patriots – vs. Indianapolis
  16. Kerryon Johnson – Detroit Lions – vs. Green Bay
  17. Mark Ingram – New Orleans Saints – vs. Washington
  18. James White – New England Patriots – vs. Indianapolis
  19. Giovani Bernard – Cincinnati Bengals – vs. Miami
  20. Matt Brieda – San Francisco 49ers – vs. Arizona
  21. Alex Collins – Baltimore Ravens – at Cleveland
  22. Dion Lewis – Tennessee Titans – at Buffalo
  23. Jay Ajayi – Philadelphia Eagles – vs. Minnesota
  24. Devonta Freeman – Atlanta Falcons – at Pittsburgh
  25. Aaron Jones – Green Bay Packers – at Detroit
  26. Phillip Lindsay – Denver Broncos – at NY Jets
  27. Dalvin Cook – Minnesota Vikings – at Philadelphia
  28. LeSean McCoy – Buffalo Bills – vs. Tennessee
  29. Adrian Peterson – Washington Redskins – at New Orleans
  30. Tevin Coleman – Atlanta Falcons – at Pittsburgh
  31. Nyheim Hines – Indianapolis Colts – at New England
  32. Bilal Powell – NY Jets – vs. Denver
  33. Royce Freeman – Denver Broncos – at NY Jets
  34. Derrick Henry – Tennessee Titants – at Buffalo
  35. Austin Ekeler – LA Chargers – vs. Oakland
  36. Javorius Allen – Baltimore Ravens – at Cleveland
  37. Duke Johnson – Cleveland Browns – vs. Baltimore
  38. Kenyan Drake – Miami Dolphins – at Cincinnati
  39. Chris Carson – Seattle Seahawks – vs. LA Rams
  40. Joe Mixon – Cincinnati Bengals – vs. Miami

Notes:

  • James Conner couldn’t have had a better start to the 2018 season, but it has gone downhill since. It hasn’t been the smoothest of seasons for Pittsburgh in general, and that was fully on display this past week as they lost to Baltimore. As we head into Week 5 there is some more clarity regarding Le’Veon Bell’s status, as he appears to be returning for Week 8 following Pittsburgh’s bye. However the Steelers are still potentially attempting to trade Bell, so it is possible that Conner does retain the job for longer than two more weeks. Regardless, we need to adjust our expectations for Conner as he gained just 44 combined yards last week; 19 on the ground while catching three of his seven targets for 25 yards. Game flow was an issue and we shouldn’t forget about him. Overall, Conner has 232 rushing yards through his first four games with 135 coming in Week 1 and 97 coming in the other three games. Prior to last week he was catching five passes per game, so despite his recent struggles it is a good sign that he has a regular role in the passing game. With a match-up against Atlanta on tap for this week, I would expect to see a rebound performance.
  • Dalvin Cook really just can’t catch a break this season. Not only is the second year running back dealing with a hamstring injury, as of Monday he was still not 100%, he follows up one tough match-up with another one. Last week he had to deal with the Rams’ defense and next up is the Eagles, so things won’t get much easier. It will likely be another few weeks until Cook is fully healthy, but having a few extra days (Minnesota played on Thursday) should benefit him. Cook carried the ball just 10 times against Los Angeles last week, all in the first half, for 20 yards and in three games he has yet to reach 100 yards (97 in total). The next time Cook reaches the end zone will be the first for 2018, and at this point I would look for another option this week.
  • There is another running back who was dealing with injury issues and was drafted to be a starting running back, who might warrant a seat on your bench again for this week. If you drafted LeSean McCoy you were counting on him to be a plug and play option, but he has yet to be up to the task. Despite talk about a focus of the game plan being to get him touches, he really wasn’t a factor against Green Bay (game flow didn’t work in his favor). Buffalo never really had a chance, and to say that Josh Allen looked over matched would be an understatement. Marcus Murphy wasn’t even active last week to take away targets from the veteran, as McCoy managed just five carries for 24 yards and three receptions for another 13 yards. All together McCoy has 29 touches in three games, so the only place to go for the veteran is up. However with the Titans having a strong defense, I might want to wait another week before putting McCoy back into my lineup and letting him prove himself. At some point Buffalo will have to lean on him.
  • Entering this season there is no way I would have expected to rank Marshawn Lynch as an RB1, but here we are. Lynch is one of the bell-cow running backs who has proven that he can be counted on each week and the workload has been there. In each of the past three weeks he has surpassed 20 touches and he’s coming off his highest yardage total (130) since 2014. Included in Lynch’s carries was a 59 yard romp in which he showed impressive speed by getting downfield. Last week he failed to get in the end zone as he was stuffed on his goal line carries, but he has 3 TD on the season while averaging 4.4 yards per carry. At this point you can’t argue with the production or the workload; 68 carries in four weeks along with 10 receptions for 60 yards. This week he shouldn’t have too many difficulties navigating the Chargers defense, and it is a hot hand to be ridden.
  • At this point we are going to assume that Devonta Freeman will return for Week 5, but as of Tuesday evening it has not been confirmed. After carrying the ball six times for 36 yards and catching three passes for another 14 yards before exiting with a knee injury, Freeman hasn’t played since. However he did return to practice on a limited basis last Thursday, so that is why we expect to see him in what will be a high scoring affair against Pittsburgh. In Freeman’s absence Tevin Coleman failed to truly get going as he has just a combined 294 yards; 54 carries for 210 yards and 10 receptions for another 80 yards. Ito Smith did factor into the equation, taking some work away from Coleman, but with Freeman back Smith will likely recede as the backfield returns to it’s natural order. It is a situation to monitor throughout the week, but based on what we have seen so far Freeman has the slight edge.
  • Sorry, not sorry Matt Patricia, but I don’t agree. Kerryon Johnson’s current workload simply is not enough. Coming off a game that saw him carry the ball 16 times for 101 yards two weeks ago against the Patriots, the rookie was on the field for just 20 snaps last week against Dallas. It’s not like Johnson wasn’t successful in that time either; nine carries for 55 yards and a touchdown. So far this season he has carried the ball 38 times, and he is averaging 5.7 yards per carry. If that doesn’t beckon for more work I’m quite honestly not sure what does.

Make sure to check out all of our Week 5 rankings:

Quarterbacks
Running Backs
Wide Receivers
Tight Ends
Kickers
Defenses
Week 5 Rankings (2018): Top 50 Wide Receivers
Week 5 Rankings (2018): Top 20 Tight Ends

41 comments

  1. Inglorious Bastards says:

    Hello Professor,

    I’m a full Point PPR, what are your thoughts on a healthier Marlon Mack as a stash now and possible taking over the lead back role…

    Also, can you help me chose a Flex out of these players: Marvin Jones, Phillip Lindsay, Aaron Jones and Dion Lewis. Thank you in advance…

  2. Inglorious Bastards says:

    Please also include Randall Cobb, if heathy and plays. Thank you

  3. keith o branstetter says:

    How do you feel about trading WR Evans for RB Michel ? My RB are AP, A Jones, Miller and Drake.

  4. Eric says:

    Hey Professor,

    Would you trade Julio and Kerryon Johnson for David Johnson and JuJu in PPR?

    Also start Breida, Hyde, Kerryon, Amari Cooper at flex?

    Thank you

  5. OtisP says:

    Is offering Lamar Miller and Corey Davis too much to pay for Devonta Freeman?

    • Not crazy, if you have the WR depth

      • OtisP says:

        Thanks Prof – I think I have enough WR depth to pull it off. In the meantime, I was just offered Frank Gore and Aaron Rodgers for Lamar Miller and James Conner. Should I do it? I still have Kareem Hunt, Tevin Coleman, and Bilal Powell at RB. As for QB, I have been streaming QBs all year so adding Rodgers would be a huge boost. Thoughts?

        • Do you start a FLEX? Regardless Conner seems like he’s about to become worthless. Any chance to get a little something better than Gore?

          • OtisP says:

            We do start a FLEX. I hear you about Gore. Also, not convinced that Rodgers is that much better than my streaming options (last week I streamed Dalton), especially given the loss of Miller. On the flipside, Miller is concerning me as well and with Conner becoming worthless in two weeks, I see it as Miller for Rodgers. Tough call for sure. I could ask for Chris Carson in place of Gore but not sure that he would go for it.

  6. Tyler says:

    I was offered Joe Moixon and Shady McCoy for Devonta Freeman, half point ppr. Would you accept that trade? Does McCoy have any upside anymore? I’m essentially looking at it as Mixon for freeman but I can’t decide which one I like better.

  7. J says:

    Brieda, Lewis or Lindsay as my RB 2?

  8. Krysta says:

    14 team, PPR. I need two of the following Carlos Hyde, Devonta Freeman, Adrian Peterson or javarius Allen?

  9. Krysta says:

    Also offered Alex Collins for Devonta Freeman if that plays into your decision at all. Thoughts?

  10. Gail Uhl Jolly says:

    Crowell has been a disappointment so far. Obviously rookie QB does not help. Give him another try or go with Jarvious Allen? I also have Ty Montgomery.
    Thanks!

  11. Matt says:

    Ppr trade collins and njoku for Sony Michelle?

  12. Touchette says:

    Start TJ Yeldon or Kenny Golladay in my flex (PPR)?

  13. Max says:

    Hello professor.
    I have a flex slot and I wanna play Kareem Hunt but I have John Brown and Emmanuel Sanders who have good matchups this week. What do you think?

  14. D'Brickashaw says:

    Who’s would you drop first? P. Barber or J. Williams?

  15. Ryan says:

    There’s a running back I don’t see on here that may have a decent week before handing his touches back to clement and sproled. What’s your feeling about Smallwood over Chris Thompson week 5? Saints have been solid vs rb pass catchers and Minnesota has been fairly generous. I have golladay, McCoy and Callaway as well to choose from.

  16. Jj says:

    Murray if cook is out or collins ? Ppr thanks

  17. Joe says:

    Week 5 i need to start 2 runningbacks and 1 at flex. My options are. James conner. Matt breida. Aaron jones. Mark ingram. Or should i start tyler boyd or landry as flex. Full ppr

    • I’d go Connor/Breida at the RB spots. I don’t trust Ingram to get enough usage for the FLEX. I’d lean Landry, with Jones as my #2 if you are more comfortable going that way

  18. Billy says:

    Who should I start at RB in a 1 point PPR league. Joe Mixon even though he will be limited in his return or Dion Lewis??

  19. Holdthedoor101 says:

    12 team PPR league. I have Coleman,J. Allen, Freeman and Enunwa. Who would you start as your flex play?

Leave a Reply to Tyler Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>