Start ‘Em or Sit ‘Em: Week 15: David Wilson, Josh Freeman, Darren McFadden & More

Trying to decide who you should start or sit this week? Let’s take a look at a few potential decisions owners have and try to sort through them:

Start – Josh Freeman – Tampa Buccaneers – at New Orleans Saints
Eli Manning showed us in Week 14 just how bad the Saints passing defense is. They have now allowed 27 passing touchdowns (tied for most in the league), while giving little pressure (25 sacks) and little threat of a takeaway (10 INT). The Tampa Bay passing attack has proven it can be dangerous, with Freeman throwing at least two touchdowns in eight of his past nine games. Back in Week 7 against the Saints all he did was throw for 420 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions. Unless you have one of the truely elite, Freeman is an easy call.

Sit – Joe Flacco – Baltimore Ravens – vs. Denver
Maybe a new offensive coordinator will help, but at this late juncture it is impossible to bet on. While Flacco did throw three touchdowns in Week 14, he also has thrown for under 200 yards in three of his past four games and takes on a Denver defense allowing 215.7 passing yards per game with 15 interceptions. There’s just too much risk involved wit your fantasy title on the line.

Running Back
Start – David Wilson – New York Giants – vs. Atlanta
Obviously, if Ahmad Bradshaw ultimately plays you aren’t going to start Wilson. However, the current signs point to him at least being limited, if he even dresses. Wilson showed just how electric he can be in Week 14, not just in the return game, but rushing for 100 yards and two touchdowns on 13 carries. The Falcons defense has been prone to the big play, allowing a league leading seven runs of at least 40 yards. They also have allowed 14 TD, fifth most in the league. With Wilson’s big play potential, he’s looking like a great play this week.

Start – Darren McFadden – Oakland Raiders – vs. Kansas City
I know he hasn’t been very good overall this season, but he has a favorable matchup against the Chiefs, the team he had arguably his best performance of the year against (137 total yards). It’s easy to write him off, but that would be a mistake.

Sit – Michael Turner – Atlanta Falcons – vs. New York Giants
The only thing that has been saving him is his ability to find the end zone, having scored in four straight games. However, he is a non-factor in the passing game and hasn’t had more than 15 carries since Week 9. The Falcons are moving in another direction and depending on a TD vulture at this point could kill you.

Sit – Vick Ballard – Indianapolis Colts – at Houston
I know it appears like he is the last man standing, but the Texans’ rushing defense is on par with San Francisco’s (90.8 yards/game, 3 TD). There’s too much risk in a tough matchup, unless you are in desperate need of an option.

Wide Receiver (Two Receiver Formats)
Start – Randall Cobb – Green Bay Packers – at Chicago
It’s a tough matchup and the Packers have a lot of weapons, but they also are committed to putting the ball in their play makers hands. He has been targeted at least six times in each game since Week 6, and this should be no different. He’s guaranteed the chances (especially with Jordy Nelson uncertain, Jermichael Finley struggling and Greg Jennings still working back into the offense) and he is so electric it won’t take much for him to make a big play.

Sit – Sidney Rice – Seattle Seahawks – at Buffalo
I’ve said it a lot, but the Seahawks offense is completely different on the road than it is at home. Throw in Rice’s dependence on the TD to hold value and this is too big of a gamble to take.

Wide Receiver (Three Receiver Formats)
Start – Josh Gordon – Cleveland Browns – vs. Washington
Gordon has emerged as the top receiver in Cleveland and we all know how bad Washington’s pass defense is. Over the past four weeks he has had at least seven targets per game and has picked up 202 yards over his past two games. He is certainly worth the risk in deeper formats.

Sit – Larry Fitzgerald – Arizona Cardinals – vs. Detroit
Has it really come to this? It’s been so bad it has to be considered, though it truly depends on your other options.  I can’t consider him a must sit (though he is in two receiver formats), but until the Cardinals fix their quarterback spot he is going to be a huge risk.

***** Pre-order the Rotoprofessor 2013 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide today for just $6!!  Expanded rankings, prospect lists, Top 25 sleepers and so much more!  To order, or for more information, click here. *****

Make sure to check out all of our Week 15 rankings:

Sunday Morning Start ‘Em or Sit ‘Em: Week 15: Robert Griffin III, Ryan Mathews, Dez Bryant & More
Thursday Night Start ‘Em or Sit ‘Em: Eagles vs. Bengals: Bryce Brown, Andy Dalton & More


  1. Randy says:

    I am behind the eight-ball after banking on the ‘upside’ of Bryce Brown. Which two do I start out of McFadden, Morris, and David Wilson? (standard league). Thanks!

    • Steve says:

      With ur options… I’d leave McFadden benched. Could tweek his damn ankle first play again. I have Wilson over McFadden in mine, then again i don’t have Morris…he’s ur best play cause their going to play it safe at QB no matter who it is that plays. GL

  2. James says:

    Moreno or Wilson in my flex? I’m good elsewhere with AP and Charles as my RBs.

  3. Randy – I would definitely roll with Morris and Wilson at this point

    James – it’s really close, but I would go Wilson at this point. He has the higher upside, but is a little bit riskier

  4. Gary says:

    What do you think of the Tenn Titans defense ability to put up some big numbers this week against NYJ? Should I start Tenn’s defense or San Francisco’s defense against NE?

  5. Idan says:

    Hi, Need help please.. I can’t decide. I have 2 spots avail and can use, Mathews, Dwyer, M. Owens or Ballard. Which 2 would you recomend to start. Thanks

  6. Cassi says:

    Help!! Reggie Bush or David Wilson?!?! Im torn because i have Eli,Hakeem, and Victor…..i also have Giants defense!!

  7. brian fee says:

    Pick top 3 of these receivers: Vincent Jackson,Andre Johnson, Randall Cobb, Miles Austin or Aaron Hernandez.

    Also pick 3 running backs from: Trent Richardson, Chris Johnson, David Wilson or Knowshon Moreno

    Which defense, Seattle or Houston

  8. Luc says:

    If Dez plays on sunday would you recommend starting him over Anquan Boldin or Brandon Gibson?

  9. Gary – it’s a bit of a coin flip and depends on yOr league scoring system. What is the points against look like? I like SF ability to make plays, but the scoring system is going to determine this one.

    Idan – Mathews for sure. As for the second choice, I would lean Owens but its a complete coin flip.

    Cassi – I want to say Wilson, but that’s wa too many Giants…lol.

    Brian fee –
    RB – Richardson, Johnson and Wilson
    WR – Jackson, Johnson, Hernandez (tough to sit Cobb though )
    D – Seattle

    Luc – absolutely

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>