Top 15 Shortstops For 2011


Shortstop is a position that has a lot of players with the potential to excel and make fantasy owners look brilliant, but very few certainties.  Even among some of the top options, you have to wonder what you are going to get.  Let’s take a look at how things currently look on our Top 15 rankings:

  1. Hanley Ramirez – Florida Marlins
  2. Troy Tulowitzki – Colorado Rockies
  3. Jose Reyes – New York Mets
  4. Elvis Andrus – Texas Rangers
  5. Jimmy Rollins – Philadelphia Phillies
  6. Derek Jeter – New York Yankees
  7. Alexei Ramirez – Chicago White Sox
  8. Starlin Castro – Chicago Cubs
  9. Stephen Drew – Arizona Cardinals
  10. Rafael Furcal – Los Angeles Dodgers
  11. Jhonny Peralta – Detroit Tigers
  12. Ian Desmond – Washington Nationals
  13. Juan Uribe – San Francisco Giants
  14. Alcides Escobar – Milwaukee Brewers
  15. Yunel Escobar – Toronto Blue Jays


  • Shortstop has quickly developed into as shallow a position as there is in baseball.  Yes, there are decent players at the bottom of the rankings, but there is only so much quality and then a ton of question marks.
  • Headlining the questions is Jimmy Rollins.  If he stays healthy he is a stud option, but at this point it is far from a lock that he does so.  While the average has struggled the past two seasons, so has his BABIP (.251, .246).  He’s not likely to produce like 2007, but he’ll score runs and is worth the gamble.
  • Speaking of staying healthy, Rafael Furcal anyone?  He has had over 400 AB just once in the past three seasons, so if you are going to draft him, I’d make sure I have an Ian Desmond or Juan Uribe on my bench.  In other words, make sure you have someone you can plug into your lineup for a few weeks, just in case.
  • It will be easy to argue Andrus’ spot in these rankings, but I stand by my opinion of him.  This is a debate that we’ll have in the near future.
  • If you can stomach a poor April, Alexei Ramirez has proven that he has the ability to be among the better shortstops in the league.  Just don’t panic when he’s hitting .200 on May 1.
  • We can all tell that Derek Jeter is slowing down, but he’s still hitting atop a loaded Yankees lineup.  That means all he has to do is hit .270 and he’ll near 100 runs scored.  If he is able to rebound at all, he could easily top 110 and maybe even approach 120.  There’s a lot to be said about that.
  • Yesterday I posted my projection for Jose Reyes, which you can view by clicking here.

What are your thoughts on these rankings?  Whose too high?  Whose too low?

Make sure to check out our early 2011 rankings:


  1. just alotta guys you dont want anything to do with, i’d rather take more for sure options at other positions and run an alexie, starlin castro, or ian desmond out there that i take later in the draft

  2. Hard to disagree with that thinking, though I certainly would love to have either of the Top 2. After that, it starts to become a real crapshoot. I like Reyes, but will he stay healthy? Same can be said for Rollins… Can Andrus hit for power…

  3. yep its the top 2….. and a roll of dice after that.

    Jeter is not the same player he once was.

    Rollins is way to injury prone for me.

    Reyes….. see rollins.

    Andrus and Castro are similiar

  4. I think Andrus was victimized by some slightly bad luck last year. His BABIP should be higher for someone who hit almost 20% line drives and over 60% groundballs last year with his speed. He increased his walk rate by 28% from 2009 to 2010 so that is always a good sign for both batting average and his stolen bases. While he puts a miniscule amount of balls in the air, a 0% HR/FB rate is not going to repeat. I think the 6 homers he had in 2009 is doable, but at just 22-years-old I don’t think we can expect much more than a handful of home runs from him in 2011.

  5. I think Reyes is worth any health risk if he’s sitting there in the 3rd, but otherwise I agree with TY on waiting for a SS late. Of the bottom 5, Desmond looks the most interesting to me for 2011.

  6. Agree with Josh, if I dont snag a top 2 (im grabbin Tulo at 4 or later after THE 2 and Miggy) then im waitin on Castro. He showed big potential at times last year.

    Also, Stephen Drew isnt the next Jake Plummer, he doesnt play for the Cardinals

  7. You’re pretty high on Starlin Castro. He’s talented for sure, but there’s a great risk of the sophomore slump especially at his age (20!) and organizational dysfunction. Love the potential, but need some info, could you do an article? Thanks


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here